ARC Review | Sister Dear by Hannah Mary McKinnon

Sister Dear by Hannah Mary McKinnon
Genre: Mystery & Thriller
Publication Date: May 26th, 2020
ARC from Netgalley

Beauty. Wealth. Success.

She’s got it all.

And it all should’ve been mine.

When Eleanor Hardwicke’s beloved father dies, her world is further shattered by a gut-wrenching secret: the man she’s grieving isn’t really her dad. Eleanor was the product of an affair and her biological father is still out there, living blissfully with the family he chose. With her personal life spiraling, a desperate Eleanor seeks him out, leading her to uncover another branch on her family tree—an infuriatingly enviable half sister.

Perfectly perfect Victoria has everything Eleanor could ever dream of. Loving childhood, luxury home, devoted husband. All of it stolen from Eleanor, who plans to take it back. After all, good sisters are supposed to share. And quiet little Eleanor has been waiting far too long for her turn to play.

| Book Review |

Sister Dear is a Mystery/Thriller from Hannah Mary McKinnon, and it was my first read from the author. Prior to reading this book, I saw some reviews that said it was more Women’s Fiction than Mystery/Thriller, and I would agree that that’s true for the first 90% of this book. But I do feel like the last ten percent was pretty edge of your seat, jaw-dropping suspenseful and thrilling. But was it as malicious as the blurb led me to believe? I don’t think so; I just enjoyed it nonetheless.

When I started reading this book, the first thing that really drew me in was the Maine setting. I love to read books about where I live. It immediately adds a layer of immersiveness that I don’t have with books that take places I’ve never been. Especially when Eleanor made a comment about the October weather, and how you never know what to wear in Maine because the weather is so fickle. Another thing that struck me right off was how much I liked our protagonist, Eleanor. More often than not, I can’t find a character to like in a Mystery/Thriller, and that’s OK. Oftentimes, I don’t think I’m supposed to for the sake of suspense. If the story on the pages can carry the book despite me not liking any of the characters, I can love it anyway. She was so sad and lonely, and I felt bad for her. That’s when I realized that I wasn’t sure if I liked her so much as pitied her, and it made me want to comfort her. Eleanor was her own worst enemy, though I’m sure she’d disagree and say that her mother and sister were. They were so malicious and cliquey; it was no wonder that when Eleanor found out she had a whole other branch to her family tree that she never knew existed, she wanted to get to know them. Maybe she’d finally be accepted instead of ganged up on.

Eleanor takes it upon herself to insert herself into her sister’s life, and I couldn’t help but like Victoria. She was so kind to everyone around her and was such a nice person. And while all this is going on, Eleanor also starts a relationship with her neighbor, and I’ll be honest, that felt rather out of place for me until the end when things started to come to a head. I won’t spoil anything for you, but I will say that I thought this story was so interesting, especially the relationship between the sisters. Instead of being competitive like she was with the sister she’d grown up with, Eleanor and Victoria were so protective of each other. That’s what makes it so hard for Eleanor to tell Victoria the truth about who she is; now that she’s finally found that closeness, it would be hard to let it go.

While Sister Dear wasn’t as Thrilling as the blurb purported, this book held its own, and was a good read for me. Like other reviewers, I would definitely recommend it to reader’s of Women’s Fiction who are looking for an ending they won’t see coming!

| Rating |

5 thoughts on “ARC Review | Sister Dear by Hannah Mary McKinnon

Add yours

  1. Blurbs can do that sometimes. Glad it was still a fabulous read about a woman finding herself and her sister even if it didn’t get exciting until the end.


  2. I love reading settings in your home state. I rarely get any in mine but Maine is one not used very often. Definitely need to see much more of that, such a beautiful state you live in. 🙂

    Sounds like a fabulous read for you and glad you enjoyed it so much.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: